Here's one I still can't figure out. Although there is probably ample proof in my personal history that I am not always the best judge of character, I thought I had this guy spot-on. Ridiculously cool, charismatic, genuine, not what you'd expect from a religious leader... so, we hired him to marry us in his church.

I'm not sure how THAT guy, and THIS guy are one in the same.

Pastor, who stole from funds for the needy, must pay up
Gambling and strippers - Members of Rex K. Loy's former congregation talk of his betrayal